Photographing the contemporary city means attempting to record all the vital signs of an extraordinarily complex and ever-changing organism; observing and discerning how the subtle can hold fascination and, at the same time, how the fascinating can distil into something unsettling and contradictory.
Every situation, every instant, every surface, movement, building, crowd, sound and rhythm contains so many layers of information and misinformation that the attempt to diagnose it—or at least carry out a kind of triage, as Kela undertakes in this series on the city of Shanghai—becomes an epic, yet absolutely necessary, endeavour.
[Parecía] un accidente ([It Seemed Like] an Accident) is the apt title Kela Coto has chosen for her project, alerting us to the paradox that emerges when two regimes of looking and two systems of image recording, functionally unequal, come into conflict: the artist’s own camera and the omnipresent surveillance cameras.
The artist attempts to photograph the city while the city watches her. Meanwhile, others take selfies or photograph themselves with their mobile devices. “…every time I took out my camera, uniformed or plainclothes police officers would appear and forbid me from taking photographs; whenever I pointed it at a street, a building or any other everyday object, I would come across a surveillance camera and facial recognition systems. All of this began to shape my photographic process. From then on, I started taking photographs at night or tried to speed up the act of taking a picture, decisions that became visible in the images.”
For an artist who often works with what is hidden, with the fragility that lies beneath appearances, Shanghai proved to be the perfect setting in which to witness the friction between two gazes occupying opposing positions in terms of visibility: her position as a photographer, observing and recording, and the constant scrutiny and recording of her own image and presence as instruments of control and self-censorship. The consequences of this friction are indelibly inscribed in her work.
In the works that make up the series, the artist documents a city transformed into a panopticon, a system that displays itself shamelessly while observing and recording us with equal impudence. It is a reality we all know and have come to accept: a watchful reality that, as the artist attempts to record it, tacitly imposes its restrictive rules, instils a sense of urgency or self-censorship, and produces small photographic accidents. “(…) in my haste, I began releasing the shutter before fully removing the film holder, or taking photographs while still adjusting the shutter speed, or making long exposures without first testing them.” This resulted in small photographic accidents: “black bands across the images, fingers or overexposures that turned buildings into ghostly beings rather than perfect icons of modernity. Control and surveillance, whether exercised through hard power, as in China, or soft power, as in the West, have a visible effect on bodies. (…) Those photographs that I had initially discarded as mistakes were not really errors at all, but physical evidence of a system of control exercised over citizens—and, in this case, over me as a photographer.”
Under these conditions, error ceases to be error and becomes explicit information about the reality we are observing. The accident does not spoil the image; rather, it becomes the very indicator that reveals a system of overlapping layers of invisibility and surveillance.
Surveillance, however, goes far beyond being a theme around which the project is constructed. Here, the system of control intervenes, indirectly but drastically, in the photographic act itself: it alters the conditions under which the artist can take photographs, shapes her gestures, changes her relationship with space and leaves its mark on the images themselves. This invisible Orwellian eye becomes tangible in the photographs, perhaps changing, in the process, the very nature of the “accident”.
The artist’s discourse turns towards a more subtle question: what happens when a system of surveillance begins to alter the way we look, even before its censorship or restrictions become explicit? Who decides what can be seen, who has the right to look, and how what is being seen should be interpreted? (Perhaps today Berger would add the notion of a disciplined gaze to his Ways of Seeing…)
Finally, Kela Coto’s photographs, which carry within them this extraordinary documentary core, have the audacity to remain utterly captivating. They masterfully strike the difficult poetic note of the urgent and accidental image, as certain lyrical works did in times of turmoil…
An expressionistic yet delicate portrait of a city that is as photogenic as it is, in Foucauldian terms, watchful.
Perhaps, in the not-too-distant future, a likely portrait of all our cities.
Laila Bermúdez y Ramón Isidoro